A simple and good poem. Two points - "உள்ளிழுக்கும் மூச்சுக்காற்றே - அடுத்தவர் வெளி மூச்சாய் இருப்ப" - that is a big scientific flaw !! We inhale oxygen and exhale carbon-di-oxide. We cannot inhale what other humans inhale. Well, I know your answer (படைப்பாளியின் சுதந்திரம் and you did not mean it literally in that way). But, for a person who likes to have his views to remain eternal in this world (காலம் காலமாய் கருத்தாகவாவது பரவி இருக்க அப்படி என்ன வோய் ஆசை ??), poems must be correct in words, meaning and content !! என்ன சொல்றீர் !!
Gowri, Correcrtion to your comment. We DO NOT just inhale oxygen alone....We take in air AS SUCH made available around us and have the technology to retain the oxygen portion of it....Got it, Pal... Do not have any doubts about it....my poems and this blog will live for ever..... (you are not "bad" or "worse"....just that you do not think while you "pass" opinions...You are sure to improve with time...Be in touch with this blog regularly....OK ???
1) Yes, I stand corrected on the scientific flaw that I mentioned.
2) Nothing lives in this world for ever. We and our creations are NO exceptions. In this case, if the "data centre" and the "backup data centre" that holds (y)our data crashes - (y)our "creations" are gone for ever. I am not saying that it will happen - but just reminding you that it is not impossible.
3) I didnt mean what you think by my word "worse" when I said - "worse critic".
4) I did not pass any "opinion". I dont consider myself fit to pass opinion on anything on anybody. This is a "COMMENT" section. COMMENT is NOT EQUAL to OPINION.
prelude :: Let me not try to translate "karuthu" into either comment or opinion.....
Thanks for your point no.1. I am not the one who can challenge you on point no.2. Though I am strongly tempted not to write any thing on your third and fourth point, the words "comment" and "opinion" put me in SABAASH mode...Will muse about this today.....!!
A simple and good poem. Two points - "உள்ளிழுக்கும் மூச்சுக்காற்றே - அடுத்தவர் வெளி மூச்சாய் இருப்ப" - that is a big scientific flaw !! We inhale oxygen and exhale carbon-di-oxide. We cannot inhale what other humans inhale. Well, I know your answer (படைப்பாளியின் சுதந்திரம் and you did not mean it literally in that way). But, for a person who likes to have his views to remain eternal in this world (காலம் காலமாய் கருத்தாகவாவது பரவி இருக்க அப்படி என்ன வோய் ஆசை ??), poems must be correct in words, meaning and content !! என்ன சொல்றீர் !!
ReplyDelete-Gowri
(do you have any other worse critic? ;) )
Gowri, Correcrtion to your comment. We DO NOT just inhale oxygen alone....We take in air AS SUCH made available around us and have the technology to retain the oxygen portion of it....Got it, Pal...
ReplyDeleteDo not have any doubts about it....my poems and this blog will live for ever.....
(you are not "bad" or "worse"....just that you do not think while you "pass" opinions...You are sure to improve with time...Be in touch with this blog regularly....OK ???
Anna,
ReplyDelete1) Yes, I stand corrected on the scientific flaw that I mentioned.
2) Nothing lives in this world for ever. We and our creations are NO exceptions. In this case, if the "data centre" and the "backup data centre" that holds (y)our data crashes - (y)our "creations" are gone for ever. I am not saying that it will happen - but just reminding you that it is not impossible.
3) I didnt mean what you think by my word "worse" when I said - "worse critic".
4) I did not pass any "opinion". I dont consider myself fit to pass opinion on anything on anybody. This is a "COMMENT" section. COMMENT is NOT EQUAL to OPINION.
"Karuthu" Anna
ReplyDeleteprelude :: Let me not try to translate "karuthu" into either comment or opinion.....
Thanks for your point no.1.
I am not the one who can challenge you on point no.2.
Though I am strongly tempted not to write any thing on your third and fourth point, the words "comment" and "opinion" put me in SABAASH mode...Will muse about this today.....!!
Anna, I remain
Suchoo alias suren